Southeast Idaho rental market snapshot — November 2026
Southeast Idaho's rental market stays tight heading into winter. Typical asking rents for a new lease run from about $1,081 a month in Pocatello to about $1,565 in Twin Falls, with Idaho Falls at about $1,396 and Rexburg at about $1,160 (Zillow's Observed Rent Index, September 2026). Rental vacancy sits between 3.9% and 5.4% across the four cities (U.S. Census), and well-priced homes keep moving — High Mountain's average time to lease is 15 to 30 days, with current occupancy at 86%. Every figure in this snapshot is sourced and dated November 2026; rents move, so check the date before quoting them.
The numbers at a glance
- Idaho Falls: typical asking rent about $1,396 a month; median gross rent $1,075; average apartment $1,535; vacancy 4.4%.
- Pocatello: typical asking rent about $1,081 a month; median gross rent $948; average apartment $1,366; vacancy 5.4%.
- Twin Falls: typical asking rent about $1,565 a month; median gross rent $1,082; average apartment $1,419; vacancy 3.9%.
- Rexburg: typical asking rent about $1,160 a month; median gross rent $1,004; average apartment $1,044; vacancy 4.0%.
- Smaller markets follow the same pattern — HUD's FY2027 fair market rent for a 2-bedroom in Bingham County (Blackfoot) is $1,017 a month.
Idaho Falls
Idaho Falls is the region's largest rental market, with about 71,785 people (64,818 in the 2020 Census) and the deepest tenant pool in eastern Idaho. Rents depend on what you measure: the median gross rent across all renters is $1,075 a month (U.S. Census, American Community Survey 2020–2024), up 38.5% over five years, while the typical asking rent for a new lease is about $1,396 in the city and $1,434 across the metro (Zillow's Observed Rent Index, September 2026, up 1.4% year over year). Apartments average $1,535 a month (RentCafe/Yardi Matrix, October 2026) — 1-bedroom $1,331, 2-bedroom $1,544, 3-bedroom $1,824 — and single-family homes rent higher, with a median house rent of $1,800 (Zumper, October 2026). HUD's FY2027 fair market rents for the metro run studio $1,013, 1-bedroom $1,064, 2-bedroom $1,274, and 3-bedroom $1,764. Rental vacancy is 4.4%, and the median sale price in Bonneville County was $375,000 in July 2026 (Snake River MLS).
Pocatello
Pocatello is the county seat of Bannock County and the largest city in southeast Idaho, with about 59,000 people in the city and roughly 92,000 across the metro. About 7,993 households in the city rent their homes — 35.5% of occupied housing — and the renter base draws on Idaho State University, Portneuf Medical Center (about 1,600 employees), the school district, and Idaho Central Credit Union. The median gross rent is $948 a month (U.S. Census, ACS 2020–2024). The typical asking rent for a new lease is about $1,081 a month across the metro (Zillow's Observed Rent Index, September 2026), with 1-bedrooms averaging about $886 and 2-bedrooms about $1,276. Apartments average $1,366 a month (RentCafe/Yardi Matrix, October 2026), down 2.4% from a year earlier, and single-family homes rent higher — AmeriTitle's September 2026 market report put the median single-family rent at $1,499. HUD's FY2027 fair market rents for the metro run studio $871, 1-bedroom $956, 2-bedroom $1,251, and 3-bedroom $1,732. Rental vacancy is about 5.4%, the highest of the four cities — and Pocatello's own housing plan, adopted in July 2026, says demand will remain high with limited supply, as home building runs slow and rising ownership costs push more households to rent longer.
Twin Falls
Twin Falls is the Magic Valley's anchor city, with about 56,000 people in the city (51,807 in the 2020 Census) and roughly 124,000 across the metro. About 7,475 households rent — 35.9% of occupied housing. The tenant pool is fed by food processing and healthcare: Chobani's Twin Falls plant, the world's largest yogurt plant, employs 1,000–2,499 people and broke ground in March 2025 on a $500 million expansion adding at least 160 jobs, while St. Luke's Magic Valley Medical Center also employs 1,000–2,499 and plans to hire 100+ physicians and advanced-practice providers over five years. Twin Falls has the region's highest asking rents: about $1,565 a month in the city and $1,559 across the metro (Zillow's Observed Rent Index, September 2026), up 3.6% and 3.1% year over year, with 1-bedrooms averaging about $1,278 and 2-bedrooms about $1,840. The median gross rent across all renters is $1,082 (U.S. Census, ACS 2020–2024). Apartments average $1,419 a month (RentCafe/Yardi Matrix, September 2026); houses average $1,897 (Zumper, November 2026). HUD's FY2027 fair market rents for Twin Falls County run studio $895, 1-bedroom $982, 2-bedroom $1,285, 3-bedroom $1,779, and 4-bedroom $2,148. Rental vacancy is 3.9%, the lowest of the four cities.
Rexburg
Rexburg is really two rental markets in one city. The whole-unit market — houses, townhomes, and apartments rented to families and non-student households — runs on the figures below, while the student market around BYU-Idaho rents by the room, typically about $300–$500 per room per month in approved single-student housing. High Mountain manages long-term whole-unit rentals in Rexburg; we do not manage BYU-Idaho Approved Housing and do not lease by the room. The median gross rent across all renters is $1,004 a month (U.S. Census, ACS 2020–2024), $234 below the Idaho median — student-housing supply keeps Rexburg rents lower than Idaho Falls. The typical asking rent for a new lease is about $1,160 a month on the metro index (Zillow's Observed Rent Index, September 2026), up 1.0% year over year, with 1-bedrooms averaging about $951 and 2-bedrooms about $1,369. Apartments average $1,044 a month (Apartments.com/CoStar, August 2026), up 3.3% year over year — studio $708, 1-bedroom $1,043, 2-bedroom $1,221, 3-bedroom $1,729. HUD's FY2027 fair market rents for Madison County run studio $1,022, 1-bedroom $1,065, 2-bedroom $1,159, 3-bedroom $1,605, and 4-bedroom $1,895. Rental vacancy is 4.0%, near the statewide rate of 3.9%.
What it means for owners
Three numbers describe every market, and they measure different things. Median gross rent (U.S. Census) covers everyone currently renting, including long-tenured tenants paying older rents — so it runs lowest. The typical asking rent (Zillow's Observed Rent Index) is what a new lease signs for today — the number that matters when you price a vacancy. HUD's fair market rents sit near the 40th percentile of what recent movers paid, utilities included, so they run below the middle of the market. When you compare your rent to "the market," check which measure you're looking at. The picture across all four cities is the same: vacancy is low, demand is steady, and well-priced, well-presented homes move. High Mountain's average time to lease is 15 to 30 days from a signed contract to an executed lease and deposit received, and current occupancy is 86%. If your rent hasn't been reviewed against today's asking rents, it may be leaving money on the table — call (208) 671-0708 and we'll quote your property.
How rents are set in Idaho
Idaho has no rent control, and state law bars cities and counties from enacting it (Idaho Code § 55-306) — so rents are set by the market, with 30 days' written notice required for an increase. There is no cap on security deposits, deposits must be returned within 21 days of move-out (up to 30 days if the lease says so), and nonpayment can be addressed with a 3-day notice under Idaho Code § 6-303. This is general information about Idaho law, not legal advice.
Who you'll work with
High Mountain is owned by Jason Gonzalez. Prior to property management, he worked in financial planning for several years, until transitioning to owning and managing a restoration contracting business. Having done work for several property management groups in Southeast Idaho, Jason felt there was a gap in the industry where more value could be provided to property owners and tenants alike, which is where he jumped in.
Thinking about renting out a property, or wondering what yours could earn? Call (208) 671-0708 for a free quote, or schedule a consultation. Office hours are 9am–5pm, Monday–Friday.
