Own a rental in Rexburg? We manage it like it's our own.
High Mountain Property Management is a locally owned, long-term residential property management company based in Idaho Falls, founded in 2022 — about 30 miles south of Rexburg. We manage rentals across all of Southern Idaho, from Boise to Victor and Driggs, including Rexburg, Sugar City, and the rest of Madison County. We handle the marketing, the tenant screening, the rent collection, the maintenance calls, and the paperwork — so your rental pays you instead of costing you weekends.
Our owner is Jason Gonzalez. Prior to property management, he worked in financial planning for several years, until transitioning to owning and managing a restoration contracting business. Having done work for several property management groups in Southeast Idaho, Jason felt there was a gap in the industry where more value could be provided to property owners and tenants alike, which is where he jumped in. When you call us, you talk to the people who actually manage your property — not a call center, and not a franchise.
Rexburg runs on BYU-Idaho — and that makes it one of Idaho's deepest rental markets
Rexburg is the county seat of Madison County, about 30 miles north of Idaho Falls, with about 40,000 people in the city (39,409 in the 2020 Census; an estimated 40,334 by July 2025) and about 55,200 across Madison County. It is a renter's town to an unusual degree: about 7,250 households in the city rent their homes — 77.0% of occupied housing and more than half of all homes in Rexburg (56.6%) sit in buildings of five or more units. The median age in the city is 21.
The engine is Brigham Young University–Idaho. BYU-Idaho estimated about 21,500 students were living in Rexburg in the Winter 2026 semester more than half the city's population falling to about 14,800 in the spring semester. That winter-to-spring swing of roughly a third is the single most important fact about owning a rental in Rexburg: demand peaks with the academic calendar, and leases, pricing, and turnover all follow it. Beyond the university, Madison Memorial Hospital employs 500–999 people, and Madison School District 321 serves about 5,720 students.
The two rental markets in Rexburg
Rexburg effectively has two rental markets, and owners need to know which one their property is in:
• BYU-Idaho Approved Housing serves single students aged 17–25, who are required by the university to live in approved housing unless they live with a parent or receive a formal exception. Approved properties use the university's standard housing contract, house men and women separately, and follow the university's Honor Code and Apartment Living Standards. Approval is granted by BYU-Idaho's Housing & Student Living Office and must be maintained — it is never automatic.
• Community housing serves everyone else: married students, students 26 and older, faculty and staff, families, and non-student renters. These are ordinary long-term rentals on standard leases — and they are the market High Mountain manages.
We don't manage Approved Housing properties — if yours is in the program, BYU-Idaho's Housing & Student Living Office can point you to approved managers. Community housing is what we manage: call
(208) 671-0708 for a free quote.
What Rexburg rentals earn
Rents depend on what you measure — and in Rexburg, on which of the two markets you're in — so here are the figures side by side:
• Median gross rent, all renters: $1,004 a month (U.S. Census, American Community Survey 2020–2024). That covers everyone currently renting, including long-tenured tenants, and it runs $234 below the Idaho median — student-housing supply keeps Rexburg rents lower than Idaho Falls.
• Typical asking rent, new leases: about $1,160 a month on Zillow's Observed Rent Index for the metro area (September 2026), up 1.0% year over year. One-bedrooms average about $951 and two-bedrooms about $1,369 on the same index.
• Apartments by bedroom (Apartments.com / CoStar, August 2026): studio $708 · 1 bedroom $1,043 · 2 bedrooms $1,221 · 3 bedrooms $1,729, with an average apartment rent of $1,044, up 3.3% year over year.
• Student housing, per room: approved single-student housing typically runs about $300–$500 per room per month, usually with furniture, internet, and utilities included; investor guides put renovated rooms near campus at roughly $400–$525. A four-bedroom house rented by the room can therefore gross well above its whole-unit rent — but only if the property holds Approved Housing status.
• HUD Fair Market Rents, FY2027 (Madison County): studio $1,022 · 1 bedroom $1,065 · 2 bedrooms $1,159 · 3 bedrooms $1,605 · 4 bedrooms $1,895. HUD sets these near the 40th percentile of what recent movers paid, utilities included, so they sit below the middle of the market.
Vacancy is low on the Census measure: the rental vacancy rate for Rexburg is 4.0% (ACS 2020–2024), near the statewide rate of 3.9%. The median value of owner-occupied homes was $395,100 (ACS 2020–2024).
Where the rentals are
Rental demand concentrates around the university and spreads south as the city grows: the campus ring and Downtown hold most of the approved student complexes — over 90% of approved housing sits within two blocks of campus — along with older homes converted to rentals; the Eastside and South Mesa neighborhoods mix houses and apartments with parks and Temple access; the Millhollow Road corridor and the south side near Teton Lakes Golf Course draw families putting down roots away from student clusters; and newer subdivisions such as Summerfield and Stonebridge hold much of the family rental stock. Just north, Sugar City is Madison County's second city and part of the same rental market.
Idaho is a landlord-friendly state
Idaho has no rent control, and state law bars cities and counties from enacting it (Idaho Code § 55-306) — so rents are set by the market, with 30 days' written notice required for an increase. There is no cap on security deposits, deposits must be returned within 21 days of move-out (up to 30 days if the lease says so), and nonpayment can be addressed with a 3-day notice under Idaho Code §6-303. (General information, not legal advice.)
What we do
• Marketing and leasing — professional listing, showings, and lease execution.
• Tenant screening — credit, background, employment, income, and rental history checks on every applicant.
• Rent collection — on-time collection with direct deposit to you.
• Maintenance coordination — vetted local vendors, handled start to finish. You set the approval threshold — most owners choose around $300.
• Inspections — every 6 months, plus move-in and move-out inspections with documented condition reports.
• Owner distributions — processed on the 10th of each month, paid by ACH (usually 3–5 business days) or check (7–10 business days).
• Owner portal and statements — online and mobile access to your statements and documents, any time.
• Vacancy Utility Guard — covers the cost of rent and utilities between vacancies (available on our 15% plan).
• Transparent
pricing — no hidden fees; you see exactly what management costs.
What it costs
| Plan | Price |
| Long-Term Residential | From 8% of monthly rent |
| Commercial | From 6% of monthly rent |
| Vacant Property | From $100/month |
All plans include a one-time $500 onboarding fee. Cancel anytime with 30 days' notice.
Call
(208) 671-0708 for a quote on your property — tell us about the home, and we'll tell you what it costs to have it managed, with no obligation.
Frequently asked questions
How much does property management cost in Rexburg?
High Mountain charges from 8% of monthly rent for long-term residential management, from 6% for commercial properties, and from $100 a month for vacant properties, plus a one-time $500 onboarding fee. Across Idaho, full-service management generally runs 5–10% of monthly rent depending on the property and portfolio size. Call
(208) 671-0708 and we'll quote your property directly — no obligation, no pressure.
How fast can you fill my vacancy?
Our average time to lease is 15 to 30 days from a signed contract to an executed lease and deposit received. In Rexburg, timing matters more than in most markets: BYU-Idaho's student population peaks at about 21,500 in the winter semester and falls to about 14,800 in the spring, so a vacancy listed ahead of a semester start moves fastest. Rexburg rental vacancy sits at 4.0% (U.S. Census, ACS 2020–2024) — well-priced, well-presented homes move, and we start marketing the moment your property is ready.
What does your management fee include?
Marketing and leasing, tenant screening, rent collection with direct deposit, maintenance coordination, move-in and move-out inspections, and online owner statements and documents. You get one point of contact and a clear monthly statement — no hidden fees.
How and when do I get paid?
Owner distributions are processed on the 10th of each month. Payments by ACH usually arrive within 3–5 business days; checks take 7–10 business days. Your monthly statement is available in the owner portal, any time.
What kinds of properties do you manage in Rexburg?
Long-term residential rentals — single-family homes, townhomes, condos, duplexes, and small multifamily properties — as well as commercial properties and vacant properties. That includes homes rented to married students, graduate students, faculty, and families, which make up Rexburg's community-housing market.
Do you manage BYU-Idaho Approved Housing?
No. BYU-Idaho Approved Housing is a separate system: single students aged 17–25 must live in university-approved properties, which use the university's standard contract and follow its Honor Code and Apartment Living Standards. We don't manage Approved Housing properties — if yours is in the program, BYU-Idaho's Housing & Student Living Office can point you to approved managers. What we manage in Rexburg is community housing: homes and rentals for married students, graduate students, faculty, staff, and families, on standard long-term leases.
Do you manage properties outside Rexburg?
Yes. We manage long-term rentals across all of Southern Idaho — including Sugar City and St. Anthony in the Rexburg area, Idaho Falls (our home base, 30 miles south), and from Boise and the Treasure Valley to Victor and Driggs and up into the Sun Valley area.
Can I cancel if it isn't working?
Yes. You can cancel anytime with 30 days' notice. We don't lock owners into long contracts — we'd rather earn the renewal every month.
What owners say
"Great people to work with" — ARRON FAIRES, Google review, 5 stars
"Honest people and great at communication. Very pleasant to work with" — Nick Huston, Google review, 5 stars
"So fantastic to work with a local management company! We are so impressed and so is the family living in the home! Thank you, High Mountain for exceeding our expectations." — Linda Lane, Google review, 5 stars
5 stars on Google.
5 stars on Google
86% occupancy across units under management
15–30 days average time to lease
From 8% of monthly rent — long-term residential
Founded in 2022 — locally owned in Idaho Falls, serving all of Southern Idaho
Ready to hand off the hassle?
Owner inquiries are answered within one business day. We're open 9am–5pm, Monday–Friday.